Opportunity or Scam? Ducky Bhai, Rajab Butt, and Nadeem Naniwala’s New Project Faces Backlash
Controversy Surrounds ‘Join Elite Group’ by Ducky Bhai, Rajab Butt, and Nadeem Naniwala
Prominent Pakistani vloggers Ducky Bhai (Saad ur Rehman), Rajab Butt, and Nadeem Naniwala recently launched a learning platform, Join Elite Group, offering paid courses on TikTok live streaming, cryptocurrency investments, YouTube growth, business startups, and e-commerce management. Despite its promising outlook, the platform has been met with widespread criticism, with many questioning its legitimacy and intentions.
About the Platform
Join Elite Group aims to cater to entrepreneurs, content creators, and professionals through a variety of courses, including:
- TikTok Live Streaming: Monetization strategies and best practices.
- Business Startups: Insights into launching and managing businesses effectively.
- Cryptocurrency Investments: Tips on trading and navigating the volatile crypto market.
- YouTube Growth: Strategies to grow and sustain a YouTube channel.
- E-commerce Management: Methods for setting up and optimizing online stores.
Backlash and Criticism
Despite the ambitious scope, the platform has been plagued by technical issues, including server crashes, high traffic errors, and sign-up difficulties, which have raised concerns about its credibility.
Journalist Sheraz Butt, with nearly half a million Instagram followers, strongly criticized the project in a viral video. He questioned the founders’ intentions, stating:
“These are the same creators who monetized their private lives like a reality show. Now, they’re selling courses on making money?”
Sheraz also mocked the relevance of their content:
“YouTube is a trend that may not last another year. Are they cashing in now by selling courses on it? It’s laughable.”
Resurfaced Remarks Add Fuel to the Fire
Ducky Bhai’s past comments have also drawn attention. In a previous podcast, he admitted, “I am not a teacher to provide knowledge.” Yet, while promoting the project, he claimed, “You have supported us for years; now it’s our turn to give back.”
Industry Voices Weigh In
Other YouTubers, including Talha Reviews, Maaz Safdar, and Ali Butt, have labeled the initiative a “scam,” urging fans to avoid it. Critics argue that free resources on YouTube, TikTok, and other platforms already offer similar guidance, often with more credibility.
Additionally, content creators worldwide provide free tutorials and resources on social media strategies, algorithms, and monetization, making the need for paid courses questionable.
The Verdict
As skepticism grows, fans and critics alike are urging caution. Many have labeled Join Elite Group a “fraud business,” highlighting the abundance of free, accessible resources already available online. The controversy surrounding the platform raises critical questions about the ethics of monetizing knowledge that can be accessed freely.
The platform’s creators have yet to address the criticism directly, leaving its future uncertain amid the ongoing backlash.
